Every agent knows the feeling. You pull up today's expired list, find a promising property, and then spend 20 minutes Googling the owner's name trying to find a phone number. You end up with three numbers that may or may not be current, no idea which email is active, and no context on who you're actually calling.
There's a better way.
The tools most agents use — RedX, Vulcan7, even basic people search sites — pull from aggregated databases that are updated periodically. "Periodically" often means quarterly or less. In a market where people change phones and emails constantly, you're frequently calling numbers that are months out of date.
The agents who convert expired listings at the highest rates aren't just calling more — they're calling with better information.
Before you dial an expired listing owner, ideally you want to know:
Their current phone number — not the one they had six months ago. Primary phone, mobile vs landline, and whether it's connected.
A working email address — many owners will respond to a well-crafted email before they'll pick up a cold call. Having a verified business or personal email gives you a second channel.
Some professional context — knowing someone is a physician, an attorney, or a business owner changes how you open the conversation. "I work with a lot of professionals in Paradise Valley" lands differently when you actually know they're a professional.
Any public flags — a lien on record, a foreclosure notice, or a bankruptcy filing changes the urgency of the conversation completely. These are public record and absolutely fair game.
County assessor records — every county publishes property ownership data. It's free, accurate, and updated when ownership changes. The downside is it only gives you the owner's name and mailing address — no phone, no email.
Public records search tools — sites like FastPeopleSearch and Spokeo aggregate phone and address data from public sources. They're free or low cost but the data is often outdated and you get no enrichment context.
Live public records APIs — this is what serious prospecting operations use. Services that combine real-time public records with web enrichment can surface current phone numbers, verified email addresses, employer information, and professional profiles simultaneously. The difference is night and day.
Google search — manually Googling "[Name] [City] real estate" or "[Name] [City] contact" still works and can surface LinkedIn profiles, business websites, and contact pages that don't appear in database searches. Time-consuming but often valuable for high-priority targets.
The agents consistently converting expired listings fastest are following a simple sequence:
Pull today's expired list from your MLS first thing in the morning. For each priority property, run an owner research lookup — address in, contact data out in seconds. Review what you find before calling. Know their name, their phone, their employer if visible. Call with context. You're not just another agent cold calling — you've done homework.
The preparation time is minimal. The conversion difference is significant.
Before you call any expired listing owner, look at how many photos are currently showing on Zillow. If there are three or fewer, the listing agent almost certainly removed the photos after expiration. This is worth mentioning in your outreach — the seller may not know it happened, and it's actively hurting them by making the property invisible to buyer's agents searching for off-market opportunities.
Leading with "I noticed your photos were removed — here's why that matters" is a much stronger opening than "I'd love to talk about re-listing your home."
ListingRater's Owner Research tool searches live public records and web sources in real time — not a database that was last updated six months ago. Try 3 free lookups, no credit card required.
Try Free at ListingRater.com →